W3C

SVG 1.1 Second Edition Disposition of Last Call Comments

5 May 2011

This version:
http://www.w3.org/2010/09/SVG1.1SE-LastCall/
Editors:
Chris Lilley, W3C.

Copyright ©2011 W3C® (MIT, INRIA, Keio), All Rights Reserved. W3C liability, trademark, document use and software licensing rules apply.

Abstract

This document outlines the way in which the SVG Working Group addressed the comments submitted during the SVG 1.1 Second EditionLast Call period.

Status of this document

During the Last Call period of SVG 1.1 Second Edition, a number of comments were received from both inside and outside of the W3C. This document summarizes those comments and describes the ways in which the comments were addressed by the SVG Working Group.

Note that the majority of this document is automatically generated from the Working Group's database of comments. As such, it may contain typographical or stylistic errors. If so, these are contained in the original submissions, and the SVG Working Group elected to not change these submissions.

This document is a product of the SVG Working Group. This document may be updated, replaced or rendered obsolete by other W3C documents at any time. It is inappropriate to use this document as reference material or to cite it as other than "work in progress". This document is work in progress and does not imply endorsement by the W3C membership.

Please send detailed comments on this document to www-svg@w3.org.

Table of Contents

IssueWG ActionCommenter Response
2331: <solidColor> references Accept No reply
2332: regarding Text layout Reject Accept
2333: more BackgroundImage/enable-background issues Accept Accept
2334: filter primitive subregion and feGaussianBlur, feTile and infinite filter input images Accept Accept
2335: Clarify feConvolveMatrix bias property Accept Accept
2336: SVG fragment identifiers - ok to have the same SVGViewAttribute twice? Accept Accept
2337: marker direction handling Accept Accept
2338: type of feFunc* Accept Accept
2339: definition of azimuth, elevation for feDistantLight Accept Accept
2340: view and animation values lists - where can I find the promised note? Accept Accept
2341: Clarify data types such as "<coordinate>+" Accept Accept
2342: Typo in 15.10 Accept Accept
2343: 15.12 Filter primitive ‘feComposite’ formula Accept No reply
2344: Update references section Accept Accept
2345: 15.17 feGaussianBlur Accept Accept
2346: previous discussion about filterRes Accept Accept
2348: direction property and the effect on text elements Accept Accept
2349: Media type registration Accept Accept
2351: Clarify that units are required on <length>s in style attribute; fix examples in text. Accept Accept
2353: Clarify coordinates for feImage. Accept Accept
2360: encoding breakage in idl conversion Accept Accept
2363: Reconcile 'stroke' presentation attributes on <image> Reject Accept
2364: SVG 1.1 may be ambiguous about the root element acting as a proximal event target Accept No reply
2376: Typos: "a IRI", "URI reference" Accept No reply
2383: pAR on image, and defer Accept Accept
2391: better changes appendix Accept Accept

Comments

Issue #2331: <solidColor> references [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2332: regarding Text layout [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2333: more BackgroundImage/enable-background issues [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2334: filter primitive subregion and feGaussianBlur, feTile and infinite filter input images [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2335: Clarify feConvolveMatrix bias property [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2336: SVG fragment identifiers - ok to have the same SVGViewAttribute twice? [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2337: marker direction handling [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2338: type of feFunc* [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2339: definition of azimuth, elevation for feDistantLight [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2340: view and animation values lists - where can I find the promised note? [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2341: Clarify data types such as "<coordinate>+" [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2342: Typo in 15.10 [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2343: 15.12 Filter primitive ‘feComposite’ formula [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2344: Update references section [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2345: 15.17 feGaussianBlur [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2346: previous discussion about filterRes [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2348: direction property and the effect on text elements [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2349: Media type registration [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2351: Clarify that units are required on <length>s in style attribute; fix examples in text. [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2353: Clarify coordinates for feImage. [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2360: encoding breakage in idl conversion [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2363: Reconcile 'stroke' presentation attributes on <image> [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2364: SVG 1.1 may be ambiguous about the root element acting as a proximal event target [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2376: Typos: "a IRI", "URI reference" [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2383: pAR on image, and defer [tracker]

Status

Emails

Issue #2391: better changes appendix [tracker]

Status

Emails