SVG 1.2 Tiny Disposition of Comments
During its Candidate Recommendation phase, a number of changes were made to the SVG 1.2 Tiny specification based on public review and implementor feedback. The SVG WG returned to Last Call to request public comment, with a test suite and interim implementation report.
During Last Call, there were 97 issues raised. Of these, the SVG WG declined to make a change on six (6) issues and explained the rationale to the commenter, all of which satisfied the commenter. Additionally, the SVG WG compromised on ten (10) other issues, making a partial change, and explained the rationale to the commenter, all of which satisfied the commenters. The SVG WG agreed with all eighty-three (83) other issues, and made the requested changes, all of which satisfied the commenter. For all changes to the specification, we tested implementations to ensure that no implementations were broken by the change.
SVG WG Resolutions:
| agree | compromise | disagree |
|---|
Commenter Responses:
| satisfied | no response | not satisfied |
|---|
Disposition of Comments:
| ID | Title | Raised on | Commenter | Response | Satisfaction |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ISSUE-2053 requiredExtensions values |
Clarify values of requiredExtensions | 2008-09-16 | Frédéric Wang | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2055 evt and event |
Define 'evt'/'event' relationship more formally | 2008-09-17 | Krzysztof Maczyński | compromise | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2056 Ref to CSS2.1 |
Consider referring to Instead of linking to CSS2.1 instead of CSS2 | 2008-09-17 | Mohamed Zergaoui | compromise | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2057 CSS text-align |
text-align incompatible with CSS | 2008-09-17 | Elika Etemad (CSS) | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2058 BIDI 'direction' |
Lack of BIDI 'direction' | 2008-09-17 | Elika Etemad (CSS) | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2059 stroking rectangles |
behaviour for stroking rectangles | 2008-09-18 | Dr. Olaf Hoffman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2060 title-desc-tooltip |
[1.2T-LC] title and desc example 'title-desc-tooltip.svg' | 2008-09-18 | Dr. Olaf Hoffman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2061 video interfaces |
play, stop, pause, resume on video | 2008-09-19 | Philippe Le Hegaret | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2062 foreignObject refs |
foreignObject content and referenced resource | 2008-09-20 | Dr. Olaf Hoffman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2064 type or typeof |
type or typeof? | 2008-09-21 | Dr. Olaf Hoffman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2065 find text |
Text selection - but what about Find Text ? | 2008-09-22 | Jeff Schiller | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2066 datatype |
datatype (5.10.1) | 2008-09-22 | Dr. Olaf Hoffman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2068 focusHighlight inheritable |
focusHighlight must be inheritable | 2008-09-23 | Chris Peto | disagree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2072 XSLT 2 |
Please add XSLT 2.0 | 2008-09-27 | Mohamed Zergaoui | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2073 constrained transformations |
inverse and constrained transformations | 2008-09-28 | Dr. Olaf Hoffman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2074 role, ARIA, and metadata |
WAI-ARIA use of @role as discussed under 'extensible metadata attributes' | 2008-09-30 | Al Gilman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2075 aria prefix |
lose the 'aria:' in role attribute examples using WAI-ARIA roles | 2008-09-30 | Al Gilman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2076 animatable role |
should @role in SVG be animatable? | 2008-09-30 | Al Gilman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2077 font-variant-anim |
font-variant not animatable | 2008-09-30 | Dr. Olaf Hoffman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2079 audio and rendering |
Better specify the effects of audio and rendering | 2008-09-30 | Doug Schepers | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2080 focusable_auto |
Clarify focusable=auto | 2008-09-30 | Erik Dahlström | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2081 animation target |
target element for an animation | 2008-10-01 | Dr. Olaf Hoffman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2082 attributeType auto |
attributeType auto | 2008-10-01 | Dr. Olaf Hoffman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2083 Paced-anim-complex |
Paced animation and complex types | 2008-10-01 | Dr. Olaf Hoffman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2084 extended syntax |
16.2.9 values attribute 'extended syntax' | 2008-10-01 | Dr. Olaf Hoffman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2085 Initial focus |
Spec unclear where focus should initially go when a document is loaded | 2008-10-01 | Niklas Hagelroth | disagree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2087 gotolocation |
Replace gotoLocation with a subset of Window.location | 2008-10-02 | Erik Dahlström | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2088 no-color-interpolation |
Painting chapter mentions optional color interpolation space, which is not described anywhere | 2008-10-03 | Jon Cruz | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2089 animateTransform underlying value |
animateTransform and underlying value | 2008-10-07 | Dr. Olaf Hoffman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2090 @aria-* atributes |
@aria-foo atributes: un-prefixed, forbidden? | 2008-10-07 | Al Gilman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2093 by 'identity' |
16.2.9 by 'identity' | 2008-10-07 | Dr. Olaf Hoffman | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2094 traitAccess accessing rules |
accessing rules for traitAccess | 2008-10-07 | Julien Reichel | compromise | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2098 script removal |
Clarification for removal of script element | 2008-10-10 | Julien Reichel | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2099 RDFa processing |
Re-use of RDFa attributes should follow RDF in XHTML processing rules | 2008-10-10 | Manu Sporny (RDFa) | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2100 @rel/@rev prefixes |
@rel/@rev values do not necessarily need to be prefixed | 2008-10-10 | Manu Sporny (RDFa) | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2101 @role processing |
@role should follow rules defined in XHTML 1.1 Role Module | 2008-10-10 | Manu Sporny (RDFa) | compromise | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2102 ligatures |
i18n comment 1: Explanation of ligatures | 2008-10-10 | Richard Ishida | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2103 Inline -progression |
i18n comment 3: Inline -progression typo | 2008-10-10 | Richard Ishida | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2104 Geometric typo |
i18n comment 2: Geometric typo | 2008-10-10 | Richard Ishida | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2105 Particular typo |
i18n comment 4: Particular typo | 2008-10-10 | Richard Ishida | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2106 Characters and glyphs |
i18n comment 5: Characters and glyphs | 2008-10-10 | Richard Ishida | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2107 Direction and bidi-override |
i18n comment 6: Direction and bidi-override attributes | 2008-10-10 | Richard Ishida | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2108 Only tb-rl |
i18n comment 7: Only tb-rl | 2008-10-10 | Richard Ishida | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2109 Up down top bottom |
i18n comment 10: Up down top bottom | 2008-10-10 | Richard Ishida | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2110 Text rendering order |
i18n comment 8: Text rendering order | 2008-10-10 | Richard Ishida | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2111 Geometric middle text |
i18n comment 9: Geometric middle of the text string | 2008-10-10 | Richard Ishida | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2112 Last in text area |
i18n comment 11: Last in text area | 2008-10-10 | Richard Ishida | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2115 authors |
Usage of "formerly" in Author list [AUTHORS] | 2008-10-13 | Helder Magalhães | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2116 linking typos |
Typos in Linking section [LINKING] | 2008-10-13 | Helder Magalhães | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2117 mix-images-text |
Images mixed with text in linking section | 2008-10-13 | Helder Magalhães | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2118 W3C link |
W3C home page link change | 2008-10-13 | Helder Magalhães | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2119 grammaro in linking |
Grammatical suggestion in Linking section | 2008-10-13 | Helder Magalhães | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2120 fragid inconsistency |
Minor inconsistency in Linking section | 2008-10-13 | Helder Magalhães | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2121 elliptical arc ref |
Elliptical arcs still referred to in minimize section [MINIMIZE] | 2008-10-13 | Helder Magalhães | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2122 quotes vs apostrophe |
Inconsistent usage of quotes and/or apostrophe in markup | 2008-10-13 | Helder Magalhães | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2123 misc typos |
Unsorted minor issues | 2008-10-13 | Helder Magalhães | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2125 cyril typos |
Cyril: General Typos | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2126 lacuna value |
consistent use of lacuna value | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2127 CR exit criteria |
CR exit criteria | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | compromise | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2128 intro audio playback |
Introduction should mention audio playback | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2129 definition clarifications |
Definition section is too long and needs clarifications (bbox, canvas, etc.) | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2130 data types clarifications |
Basic Data Types section needs clarifications | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2131 ambiguous baseProfile syntax |
Syntax for baseProfile is ambiguous | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2132 confusing attribute definitions |
Attribute definitions are confusing | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2133 title-desc typo |
title/desc typo | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2134 use element ambiguities |
Ambiguities in the 'use' element | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | compromise | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2135 image element ambiguities |
Ambiguities in the 'image' element | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2136 unconditional love |
Add explanation for children of container elements with false conditional attributes | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2137 canvas negotiation begin time |
Add clarification about begin time for canvas negotiation | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | disagree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2138 SVG-HTML error processing |
Error processing differences in SVG and HTML | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | compromise | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2139 eRR and prefetch |
Add note regarding eRR attribute and prefetch element | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2140 mediaSize ambiguities |
Ambiguities in mediaSize | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2141 prefetch encoding |
prefetch encoding: UTF-8/UTF-16 | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2142 metadata attributes unclear |
Use of metadata attributes unclear | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2143 clipping and overflow |
Clarify clipping and overflow | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2144 buffered-rendering v static |
'buffered-rendering' property vs 'static' | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2145 media/document timeline |
Clarify media timeline and document timeline | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | compromise | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2146 event dispatching contradictions |
Contradictions in event dispatching | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2147 external-refs confusing |
Section on externally referenced documents confusing | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | compromise | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2148 script outside document |
Clarify script outside rootmost svg element | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2149 polygon paced interpolation |
Paced interpolation of polygons | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | disagree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2150 'required' attribute |
Clarify 'required' attribute | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2151 metadata attribute feature strings |
Add feature strings for metadata attributes | 2008-10-13 | Cyril Concolato | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2152 de-emphasize 'xml:id' |
Less Emphasis on 'xml:id' | 2008-10-14 | Doug Schepers | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2153 RNG link |
Link to RelaxNG Schema | 2008-10-15 | Doug Schepers | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2158 getSetTrait-url |
get and setTrait with url() syntax | 2008-10-24 | Cameron McCormack | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2159 InvPath |
Invalid path data error/unsupported | 2008-10-24 | Cameron McCormack | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2160 BadThrowHref |
Throwing INVALID_ACCESS_ERR when setting <use xlink:href=""> | 2008-10-24 | Cameron McCormack | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2161 SVGnsreq |
SVG element namespace requirement | 2008-10-24 | Cameron McCormack | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2162 rmvpdef |
Remove "SVG viewport" definition | 2008-10-24 | Cameron McCormack | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2163 contextrole |
role="contexthelp" | 2008-10-24 | Cameron McCormack | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2164 fsbrcr |
Feature strings for buffered-rendering and color-rendering | 2008-10-24 | Cameron McCormack | compromise | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2165 ITS |
Internationalization Tag Set attributes in SVG | 2008-10-24 | Felix Sasaki | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2167 zoomAndPan |
SVG "zoomAndPan" attribute for UI controls only | 2008-10-30 | Duncan Loveday, Robin Berjon | agree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2168 display-align inherit |
Inheritance of display-align | 2008-10-30 | fantasai (CSS) | disagree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2169 ligature glyph coordinates |
Effect of ligatures on glyph coordinates | 2008-10-30 | fantasai (CSS) | disagree | satisfied |
| ISSUE-2171 direction text-anchor text-align |
text-align and text-anchor with direction | 2008-10-31 | Richard Ishida (I18N) | agree | satisfied |