Issues are marked as follows:
By: David Håsäther (hasather@gmail.com)
Summary: Editorial corrections.
AGREED
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Error in script example
AGREED
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Suggestion to rephrase some text in Terminology and Conventions
AGREED
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Clarification of DOM3Core reference
Status: Edited the paragraph to make the references more clear.
AGREED
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Define which IDL syntax is being used.
Status: Needs research into DOM Bindings spec.
AGREED
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Language bindings
Status: NSResolver removed, no function overloading, and so no longer relevant
NOT APPLICABLE
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Rephrase processing requirements for APIs
Status: Modified based on suggestions.
AGREED
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Clarify the requirements to use the NSResolver
Status: Edited text to more clearly reference requirements.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: ECMAScript authors using a Function in place of an Object for NSResolver
Status: Defined that ECMAScript implementations must support both functions and objects.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Refer to "callers" or "conforming applications" instead of "authors"
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Refer to "implementation" instead of "user agent"
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Rephrase requirements for handling namespace prefixes
Status: Updated spec with suggested text.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Define what an invalid selector is
Status: Referred to definition in Selectors.
AGREED
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Suggested requirement for UA to support same set of selectors as in CSS
Status: Added SHOULD level requirement to spec, but allowed for exceptions.
AGREED
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Define requirements for processing selector group
Status: Updated spec to refer to Selectors grammar.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Ambiguous note about default namespace URI not needing to be defined
Status: Rephrased note to be more clear.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Purpose of note about pseudo-elements is unclear
Status: Moved and rephrased as an advisory to authors about the use of pseudo-elements.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Fix grammar of example text
Status: Updated spec with suggested text.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: efine expected behaviour of NSResolver for all possible input
Status: Rewrote conformance requirements for it.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Grammatical issue with conformance requirement.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Define what "similar constructs" means in context
Status: Removed the unnecessary phrase from the spec.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Define requirements to handle NSResover as an ECMAScript Function
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Define requirements to handle non-string values
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Explain different handling of empty string for prefixes and default namespace
Status: Explained, no change to spec.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Refer to "callers" instead of "user agents"
Status: Resolved as part of comment 11.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Typo in "insensitive"
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Diego La Monica (IWA/HWG) (d.lamonica@webprofession.com)
Summary: Use XHTML syntax for example
Status: Rejected on technical grounds.
REJECTED
By: Al Gilman (Alfred.S.Gilman@IEEE.org)
Summary: Praise and worship of the spec :-)
Status: No action required.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Steven Pemberton (steven.pemberton@cwi.nl)
Summary: Clarify security considerations
Status: Initally attempted to rephrase, but ended up removing it along with the removal of NSResolver.
NOT APPLICABLE
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Define requirements for dealing with hostile behaviour from NSResolver
Status: NSResolver was removed, no longer relevant
NOT APPLICABLE
By: Sergey (castonet@yahoo.co.uk)
Summary: Add feature string for hasFeature()
Status: Added mandatory feature string
AGREED
By: Sam Weinig (weinig@apple.com)
Summary: Change StaticNodeList to NodeList
Status: Changed to match existing implementation.
AGREED
By: Sergey Ilinsky (castonet@yahoo.co.uk)
Summary: Predefine xml and xmlns prefixes for selectors
Status: Rejected on technical grounds.
REJECTED
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Fix incorrect markup
AGREED
Summary: Clarify case sensitivity of namespace prefixes
Status: Made case sensitivity more explicit, fixed examples.
AGREED
Summary: If case insensitive, require Unicode Case Folding for namespace prefixes
Status: NSResolver was removed, no longer relevant
NOT APPLICABLE
Summary: Require Unicode Normalisation NFC
Status: Rejected due to incompatibility with other existing features and increased complexity for authors.
REJECTED
By: Bert Bos (bert@w3.org)
Summary: No comment from CSS WG
Status: No response.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Change to single NodeSelector interface
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: liorean (liorean@gmail.com)
Summary: Introduce a element rooted selectors (:scope or similar)
Status: Out of scope, but can be considered for future.
REJECTED
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Support the interface to DocumentFragments
AGREED
By: liorean (liorean@gmail.com)
Summary: Support the interface on Entity and EntityReference objects
Status: The interfaces have poor support in existing UAs, adding more to them would not help.
REJECTED
By: Lachlan Hunt (lachlan.hunt@lachy.id.au)
Summary: Define how to handle null and undefined parameters
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Stringify any object returned by NSResolver
Status: Spec already matched desired behaviour, no change necessary.
AGREED
By: Lachlan Hunt (lachlan.hunt@lachy.id.au)
Summary: Clarify handling of :link and :visited pseudo classes
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Bjoern Hoehrmann (derhoermi@gmx.net)
Summary: Define how to handle leading and trailing whitespace
AGREED
By: Sam Weinig (weinig@apple.com)
Summary: Define behaviour of |div and *|div
AGREED
By: Anne van Kesteren (annevk@opera.com)
Summary: Remove raises clause from IDL
AGREED
By: João Eiras (joao.eiras@gmail.com)
Summary: Several questions about the API
Status: No spec changes requested
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Kartikaya Gupta (kagupta@rim.com)
Summary: Another question about the API
Status: No spec changes requested
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Lachlan Hunt (lachlan.hunt@lachy.id.au)
Summary: Remove or replace NSResolver with a new, less problematic solution
Status: NSResolver has been removed, could be considered for a future version of the spec
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: NSResolver moving nodes between documents
Status: NSResolver was removed, no longer relevant
NOT APPLICABLE
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Allow for security exceptions to be thrown
AGREED
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Why does the default namespace have to be resolved?
Status: NSResolver was removed, no longer relevant
NOT APPLICABLE
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Fix IDL to properly indicate return value of lookupNamespaceURI
Status: NSResolver was removed, no longer relevant
NOT APPLICABLE
By: Boris Zbarsky (bzbarsky@MIT.EDU)
Summary: Should parameter for resolving the default namespace be null or ""
Status: NSResolver was removed, no longer relevant
NOT APPLICABLE
By: John Resig (jresig@mozilla.com)
Summary: Scope all selectors within the chain to match only child elements
Status: The proposal for the :scope/:context pseudo-class is a more appropriate solution
REJECTED
By: John Resig (jresig@mozilla.com)
Summary: Combinator rooted queries
Status: Introducing :scope/:context partially addresses this problem, however may be considered for v2
REJECTED
By: John Resig (jresig@mozilla.com)
Summary: Provide more specific error diagnosis information
REJECTED
By: Gavin Kistner (gavin@phrogz.net)
Summary: Typo in example
AGREED
By: Gavin Kistner (gavin@phrogz.net)
Summary: Issue about the liveness of NodeLists
Status: Clarified the intent and effect of the spec, no change required
REJECTED
By: Gavin Kistner (gavin@phrogz.net)
Summary: Clarify example to make it clear that the order of selectors used doesn't matter.
AGREED
By: Gavin Kistner (gavin@phrogz.net)
Summary: Fix example in regards to subtree matching
Status: Example was correct, explained the misunderstanding to the reviewer.
REJECTED
By: Gavin Kistner (gavin@phrogz.net)
Summary: Rename methods again
Status: Current names already have WG consensus.
REJECTED
By: Kartikaya Gupta (lists.webapps@stakface.com)
Summary: Define in which Java module this API belongs.
Status: Updated IDL
AGREED
By: Krzysztof Maczyński (1981km@gmail.com)
Summary: Change the term "context node" to something else
REJECTED
By: Krzysztof Maczyński (1981km@gmail.com)
Summary: Use various more appropriate terms
Status: Changed some of the terms
AGREED
By: Krzysztof Maczyński (1981km@gmail.com)
Summary: Claim about pseudo-element matching being changed by CSSWG
Status: Reviewer misunderstood the issue
REJECTED
Summary: Revise Interoperability Considerations
AGREED
By: Daniel Glazman (daniel.glazman@disruptive-innovations.com)
Summary: CSS WG has no official comment
Status: Appreciated.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Kartikaya Gupta (lists.webapps@stakface.com)
Summary: Remove definition of scope element, which isn't used yet
Status: Removed
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
By: Sean Hogan (shogun70@westnet.com.au)
Summary: Introduce a matchesSelector() method
Status: Deferred to version 2.
REJECTED
By: Cameron McCormack (cam@mcc.id.au)
Summary: Editorial changes, remove redundant statment about null/undefined, update WebIDL ref.
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
Summary: SVG WG Comments
Status: Agreed with or reached compromise on most changes, rejected a few
CLOSED BY REVIEWER
Summary: Require normalisation or add a note about the issues involved to the spec
Status: This spec is the wrong place to address the issue. The CSS WG's Selectors spec is more appropriate
REJECTED